UPCOMING Webinars & Events19 Jan 2027
Employment Rights Act: January 2027 Update
Getting ready for the 2027 employment law changes: free webinar
12pm
Articles
HMRC clarifies its interpretation of 'substantial'
Gains that qualify for business asset disposal relief (BADR) are taxed at a reduced rate of 10%, but relief for company shares is not available if the underlying company carries on substantial non-trading activities. HMRC has long applied a strict 20% test, but a recent Upper Tribunal case has forced HMRC to backpedal and further clarify the interpretation of ‘substantial’.
In Assem Allam vs. HMRC [2021] UKUT 0291, the Upper Tribunal found that previous HMRC guidance using a simple 80/20 test of trading versus non-trading activity is not always going to produce the correct answer when deciding if the relief is available. HMRC guidance has not completely done away with the 20% test, but less emphasis is now placed on it.
In any dispute with HMRC, it is important to remember that a decision of the Upper Tribunal makes the law, but HMRC guidance does not have the force of law.
Upper Tribunal approach
The Upper Tribunal concluded that the legislation does not provide for a strict numeric test. The test of whether non-trading activities are substantial is a holistic one not confined to physical human activity, but requires an overall consideration of what it is that the company does.
Other factors than those listed in HMRC’s guidance can also be relevant.
HMRC guidance
HMRC’s revised guidance now states that the 20% test is only likely to be relevant when considering the level of non-trading income and the value of a company’s non-trading assets. If neither exceed 20%, HMRC will generally accept that the relief is available without further enquiry.
Having investment property may therefore preclude claiming BADR. However, there is a bit more leeway when it comes to a large cash balance because it may be argued out of the equation as being required for trading purposes.
HMRC’s guidance on the meaning of ‘substantial’ can be found here within their capital gains manual.
If you have any questions on this or any related matter, pleasecontact us
More & Other Musings
View all related contentUPCOMING Webinars & Events19 Jan 2027
Getting ready for the 2027 employment law changes: free webinar
NEW News18 Nov 2026
Justin Williams and Gregory Ellis promoted to Partner. Discover their new roles and future plans in the firm and wider Shaw Gibbs Group.
NEW Articles18 Nov 2026
Congratulations to David Gibbs, tax partner in our London office who has been recognised for his years of support for AGA
NEW News13 Nov 2026
We are pleased to report that services have returned to normal operating levels.
NEW Guides & Publications11 Nov 2026
In this edition of Alliotts Focus we look at; The Key Business Outcomes from Budget 2026, Making Tax Digital, Pension Inheritance Traps, and Taxing Crypto Assets